A portion of a ShineSparkers interview with Jack Mathews, former Technical Lead Engineer on the first three Metroid Prime games
SS: Developing one of the greatest video games ever made can’t have been a completely smooth ride. Can you tell us of any significant problems that came up in development, or disagreements within Retro?
JM: On Prime 1 specifically, Retro was kind of this thing that was exploding all around us. During the development of the game, Retro got cut in half, then cut in half again. Between that and all the leaks that were being reported at the time, we just tried to put our heads down and show everyone we could make a great game as a team. It was kind of a “fuck the haters” mentality, especially after the E3 redemption.
SS: Why do you think that Echoes’ multiplayer mode should never have happened? It would be interesting to hear what you feel could have been done differently.
JM: Well, I just feel that the game should have been either one or the other. Metroid Prime Hunters did this really well – it knew it was a multiplayer game and spent all its marbles there. When we started development on Prime 2, multiplayer was actually going to be the focus (I think we internally thought of the project as Metroid Prime 1.5). We were even going to have the ability to play as a Space Pirate and have things like wall grabs and such.
As we moved back towards a primarily single-player focus, we should have ditched multiplayer altogether. There was a ton of effort put forth to make multiplayer happen: we had to actually author third person Samus animations, we had to have support for multiple “players” in a game world, we needed to author all new lower quality effects, add game modes, et cetera et cetera. It’s all work that took quality and mindshare away from the single player.
Plus, as a Metroid fan, I just feel like single-player is how the IP should stay – seeing multiple people run around as Samus never felt right.
Full interview link: https://shinesparker...s/jack-mathews/
About Prime 2's multiplayer, I agree it was shoved in as an afterthought. It took resources away from single player and it wasn't as robust as Metroid Prime Hunters (though Hunters had the opposite problem -- single player was shoved in as an afterthought and that took resources from multiplayer). We could only wonder what if Prime 2 didn't have multiplayer or could have had fully, fleshed out multiplayer. We could also wonder how Hunters could have gone with a fully, fleshed out single player or no single player.
Edited by Ngamer01, 27 January 2018 - 01:54 PM.